Poorly managed awkward lift leads to crush death
22 June 2015
A father-of-two died when a metal frame being loaded onto a lorry trailer by a forklift fell on top of him.
Jonathan Newham, 52, of Skegness, died in hospital from head and chest crush injuries following the incident at George H Kime and Co in Wrangle, near Boston, Lincolnshire, on 10 July 2012.
The George H Kime and Co incident was investigated by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and the company was charged with serious safety breaches.
Lincoln Crown Court heard that George H Kime and Co had transported a consignment of goods from Wiltshire to Wrangle in readiness for the items to be auctioned in Skegness.
Mr Newham and a colleague were using forklift trucks to move the goods, which were not on pallets, from the trailer to a second vehicle, as the trailer was needed elsewhere.
Mr Newham had moved a large metal-wheeled chassis, also known as a ‘dolly’, from the first trailer. His colleague then attempted to load the dolly onto the second trailer.
• Goods not on pallets.
• No safe system of work for un-palletised lifts.
• Load was unsecured.
• Worker un-necessarily in a danger zone.
• Strong management absent, said HSE.
• Firm ordered to pay approx. £185,000 in fine and legal costs.
For unknown reasons, Mr Newham climbed onto the second trailer. As his colleague loaded the dolly onto the trailer with the forklift, it fell off the tines of the forklift truck, trapping and fatally injuring Mr Newham underneath.
HSE’s investigation identified that George H Kime and Co had failed to ensure the safety of their employees during the movement of the metal dolly. They had failed to plan and supervise the lift and there was no safe system of work in place for the movement of loads not placed on pallets. The forklift truck drivers were trained and competent to move items on pallets.
The court heard the Company should have made sure there was someone in charge who was qualified to plan the lift to ensure it was suspended securely, and to ensure that the item could be safely placed down after being moved. A properly planned and supervised lift would have resulted in the risks being identified and controlled and exclude people from the area. The court heard that whilst the company had some procedures in place, the absence of strong management systems meant that the Company was complacent about the risks and failed to ensure that the procedures were followed.
George H Kime and Co Ltd of Main Road, Wrangle, was fined £125,000 and ordered to pay £61,935 in costs after pleading guilty to breaching Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.
After the hearing, HSE Inspector Sally Harris said: "Mr Newham’s death was entirely avoidable and his life was needlessly lost.
"Lifting large, heavy and awkward items requires planning by a competent person and safe systems of work.
The Handling & Storage Solutions Safer Logistics Campaign
Handling & Storage Solutions continues the Safer Logistics campaign to promote health and safety awareness in logistics in 2015.
We were inspired to launch the campaign by the Health and Safety Executive encouraging all stakeholders to show leadership and ‘be part of the solution’.
It is vital to push home the message that poor health & safety practices have no place in the modern logistics world.
What you can do
Clear safety first principles are worth repeating.
- If you doubt the safety of a working practice, stop. Talk to your supervisor or manager and agree a safe way of proceeding. Don’t carry on and hope for the best.
- No matter who you are in the management structure or workforce, take responsibility for your safety, don’t assume someone else has taken care of it.
"Lifting operations, which often present severe risks to workers, must be properly planned, controlled and adequately supervised. By taking these steps, businesses can prevent tragic incidents such as this from happening.”
Speaking after the court hearing, Mr Newham’s wife of 33 years, Mrs Gillian Newham, said: "It is difficult to describe what we as a family lost on that terrible day. John and I were very much in love.
"We had raised a family and now it was our time to do the things we had dreamed about. We had big plans for the house, holidays abroad and were excited about a future that John had worked so hard to provide for.
"It all ended that day and our hopes and dreams were shattered. John was my strength, my rock and my comforter. He is missed enormously. He was quite simply a marvelous, selfless husband and father.”